Showing posts with label Professional Genealogy Services. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Professional Genealogy Services. Show all posts

21 December 2024

YOUR ANCESTORS LIVED THROUGH HISTORY AND WE ARE TOO! I CANNOT MATCH THE STRENGTH and COURAGE OF MY ANCESTOR, ROSE

It's always a pleasure to research and write this genealogy blog which includes American History with it's main focus being genealogy in the United States and for Americans. 

I was reminded recently that we too are living through history.

The other day I was showing a new friend some photos I had found, my immigrant ancestors on their 50th wedding anniversary, which took place in the 1950's. My new friend comes from one of the oldest American immigrant heritages there is - Dutch into New Amsterdam. His heritage has been part of is family story as long as he can remember, including the name of the wooden sail ship his ancestors were on that came across the Atlantic in the 1600's. I, on the other hand, had almost nothing to go on but the names of my grandparents.

I told him the story of my ancestors in particular the woman named Rose, whose strength and courage I cannot match.

All I had known as a girl of ten, who was beginning to understand that I was actually related to some of the people I met when we visited, was that Rose had been an orphan. I didn't know until years later that in Europe an orphan was a fatherless child, but Rose had been "Double Orphaned." It was assumed she had been alone as a child, without siblings or relatives. 

Rose passed before I had any idea that I should be asking questions and what those questions should be. So, on a trip to visit relatives years later, I asked her youngest daughter, "How was Rose orphaned?"

The story came forward sans any details.  One parent "burned up in a fire" and the other was "killed on the road."

When Rose was in her 80's she stayed with this relative for a couple weeks summer vacation. One morning she was up especially early. She explained that she had just had the most wonderful dream. She explained that in her dream a man had come to her and said, "At last I have found you!"  Then, in the dream, they danced and danced and danced.

Rose was a humble women who always wore a long house dress and an apron and it was not easy to imagine her dancing. One wondered if she'd had a boyfriend before marrying at nineteen and coming to American with a baby onboard the steamship.

The man she had dreamt about turned out to be a brother!

All these years later, scraps of stories that I overheard, or that were all that was left of memories that may have been considered too horrible to relay to children, have been rooted in genealogy research and embellished with historical and cultural research.

Rose, it turns out, was the result of a marriage of a woman who had been widowed and a man who had been widowed twice. Her mother had three children, so she had three half siblings. Rose's father (who most think was the one "killed on the road" was thus the step-father to three. She also had two brothers, who had come to America but decided to go back to Europe after they realized the conditions they would have to live in if they worked in factories here rather than farms there.

But, Rose said, "When we were orphaned, my brother" (the one who had come to her in a dream) said, "Don't worry, you will always have me."

What happened to him?

"He went down with the ship."

For years now I have from time to time worked on finding out what ship and when it went down.  It was not the Titanic (everyone asks). Though I don't have the name of the ship, or know if he was on crew or a passenger, through genealogy I've been able to narrow the years this could have happened between a visit or immigration of his wife and her remarriage in Europe a few years later.

As a woman who lost both of her parents as a child, likely before the age of thirteen (the death records are nowhere to be found), and who went to work that young, who married a man their friends arranged, and immigrated to America, Rose was likely traumatized, yet she and her children prevailed, She not only come to America with a baby in her arms but also have birth to many more children.

I sometimes weep a bit for Rose but I more often think that compared to her I'm weak and cowardly!

I take inspiration from her...

I'm proud to have met her!

How do ancestor's figure in your story?

Happy Holidays!

Christine

C 2024 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot


30 November 2024

THE ARCHIVES and LIBRARIES OF NATIONS : SOME RESEARCH NOTES

Each country's archives we visited so far have a different point of view about what is important, are at a different stage in the progress of digitalization, have different levels of help from archivists and librarians to the general public who are employed there, and the collections may specialize or have have categories that are different one from the other.

I believe strongly that historical research is important to any Genealogy quest. Research the location by city, county, country - watch how borders and governments (including Kings, Queens, and noble rule) and seek out maps too. If your ancestors have taken part of any historical event (such as the founding or development of the city) there may be biographies of them in history books. 


15 October 2024

INTERVIEWING RELATIVES ! FORMAL AND INFORMAL INTERVIEWING

Originally posted On September 10th 2014...



Soon Thanksgiving will be here, and then the Holidays.  Of course, your best time to interview relatives may be when you go on a visit to them and life isn't overly busy.  Still, I find that visiting people during the holidays is a good time to talk about Old Days.



INTERVIEWING RELATIVES !  FORMAL AND INFORMAL INTERVIEWING

Some people respond to formal interviews better than others.

To do a FORMAL INTERVIEW you:

1) Contact the person and tell them that you want to interview them about the family history or focus on a specific aspect of family history.  Although this can be on the phone, in person is best.  Other people in this person's life need to give you both time and space and not interrupt.

2) Set up a time to focus on just that in advance that's good for both people, and be there.

3) Be prepared with a list of questions (at least to get you started) and a recording device.
(Whatever works for you.  Some people are still using cassette machines.  Some people are settling up more than one machine at a time "just in case" one of them fails."  Recording is sometimes a more natural process as taking notes can also be distracting or stop the process. You want to make eye contact, be comfortable, and listen too!)

The recording device sometimes intimidates people.  It may make the interview feel too important or heavy. You should tell them you intend to use one before hand, but it may help to put it out of the sight line.  Test your recorder to be sure it will pick up a voice from a few feet away.  Preserving the voice of a relative as they tell their story or give information can be very valuable, if you can keep doing technology updates with original recordings.  Our voices tell so much about us!

4) Set up water or tea or other beverages before you begin.  Avoid breaking the interview with eating food or other activities. Get into the flow.

5) If, however, it's going to be a long interview or a series of interviews, try to do the interview first before taking a meal or long break or wait until after the meal.  You and your interviewee will probably respond best to knowing how it's going to go.

To do an INFORMAL INTERVIEW you:

1) Show up and seize the moment. (It's good to have that recording equipment close.)

2) Let the other person pick the topic or gently guide them to what you want to know.

3) Lends itself more than a formal interview to including more than one person.

C 2014 - 2024 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot  
All Rights including Internet and International Rights

08 March 2023

HOW TO DEAL WITH SURNAME MYSTERIES #2 THE RATHER RECENT NOTION OF SURNAMES : JEWISH

HOW TO DEAL WITH SURNAME MYSTERIES  #2  THE RATHER RECENT NOTION OF SURNAMES  : JEWISH

In the history of humans, the need for surnames is rather recent. 

We live in a world where just about everyone has two given names and a surname that, if a person desires a change, must be changed legally, which can be expensive. This formality and recent exactitude is one of the reasons we think that spelling the name as we know it to be when using a database, is the only thing to do. In genealogy though, in searching for those documents that proof our research work, we have to see it to believe it and here is a lot of missing information or inaccuracies to deal with. We have to make a judgement call sometimes on to accept or reject what we found and know why we did so in order to explain that process in our publication.

The use of surnames rose up with population increases, and the ability for people and governments to keep documents and often the decision a government made to start with demands for legal surnames has much to do with - you guessed it - statistics meant to be used to plea for funding or taxation.  

Handwritten records came first, of course. Sometimes only the educated - the priests and nuns - the nobles and aristocrats - went to school to learn to read and write. For some time the highest ranking people did not learn to read and write but considered this the role of scribes or servants. Then came the printing press, then the typewriter, then the word processor, and now here we are with computer.

***

By the way, those questions of the census' 'Do you read and write?' don't mean that the person was fluent or actually read much. Being able to sign your name might be enough to indicate that the answer should be yes. Remember that census may be the backbone of American genealogy but there can be misinformation on it. To this day no one is hooking you up to a lie detector or asking you to put your hand on the Bible when you answer the enumerator's questions. (And your landlord or neighbor may be the one reporting and not know what they are talking about!)

Unlike today in the United States, when we have education that is provided free and the majority stay in school through twelve years of education, back in the day it wasn't at all uncommon for children, especially children in agricultural regions where they actually worked from a very young age, to not go to school at all. Even a third-grade education was sometimes considered enough. The child would learn the basics of reading and arithmetic (math) and it was up to them to pursue advancing their knowledge in these basics by using what was taught. We had child labor, even in the coal mines. Even in the 20th century, some people made it through the eighth grade and then went to work, into service,  Becoming a live in nanny or a maid was considered good training for a girl who would become a wife and mother. Others quit high school to go to work and help support the family. 

Another aspect of education that is culturally significant for many of us is that there was a system of apprenticeships and trade guilds in place. A boy, usually not a girl though there were exceptions, would be taken underwing by other men, often his father or an uncle, to teach him the trade and a way to support himself and his future family. Now people who want to learn a trade go to a school and hope they can do an internship and then get paid employment for someone they are probably not related to. Factories took over so much production that was hands-on, such as leather work and the making of shoes, that there are not so many tradesmen left and the guilds have been replaced at best with Unionization. 

***

Surnames evolved and may not be consistant.

EXAMPLE

In Eastern Europe, Jewish people lived in their own religious culture, mixing with people of other ethnic people in the market, in commerce, and in other ways - certainly there were friendships - but generally returning to their own when it came to personal life and choices - such as in marriage and the practice of their religion. Within their culture, everyone who mattered was known to them, and the tradition was to identify a child by also mentioning the first name of their father or even simply using a nickname. So, your friend Izzy, formally Isaack, whose father was Yosef, back in the village in Poland, might go with the name Yosefowicz but in the United States go by Josephson...

It is common for us also to assume that 'Jewish" names are identifiable as German or German Jewish, but Jewish surnames were adapted by the country the person was living in, the dominant culture at the time. As an example, when some Jewish people left Southern Poland and went into Hungary, they Hungarian-ified their surnames. (And a note here that Sephardic Jews had surnames that are Spanish or Portuguese in origin.)

Sometimes taking on a surname had little to do with taking one of your own choice at all.  Surnames were sold and paid for in some places - and there might not be an extended family agreement on the name. If you had the money, you might end up with generations of your family being able to use the surname Diamond, Sapphire, or Ruby, or if you were a tradesperson (i.e. what we call Blue Collar now) you might go with a surname that reflected your profession - some form of Carpenter or Weaver or Baker, but if you were poor, if  you had no money, some person - an official  maybe a snob - might give you one of the free surnames that reflected your poverty and lowly position in life.  What a good reason to change your name upon coming to America!

Now that we know that we not only have to check the spelling for meaning, but also check the language for meaning, we might also realize that some people changed their names when they came to America for a new start. (The often repeated "changed at Ellis Island" is a myth both the official web site and I deny. I believe that individuals simply changed their own names for a variety of reasons, including ease, to put an end to the discrimination they had experienced in the Old Country, or to blend into the new culture.

Some people decided they just were not that into being Jewish anymore. I've met several researchers who found out someone in their heritage was Jewish along the way and without a DNA test which was surprising to them. Back in the day to be Jewish was to be Orthodox or Hassidic, not Reform, and sometimes a person just didn't feel so religious.

If you are doing Jewish research, you will also want to work with the Hebrew names granted children at birth, which are not the same as the public name the person used. If unable to read it yourself, you may need someone fluent in Hebrew to decode certain records and old tombstones with Hebrew letters on them often give up lots of good information. ***

This post is one of a series on the subject.  Click on the tag Surname Help - AWG to get to the posts.

C 2022-2025 Ancestry Worship Genealogy BlogSpot

All Rights Reserved including Internet and International Rights

image from Graphics Fairy

*** A note here on my fairly recent Opinion piece about tombstone projects and allowing the dead and the alive relatives of dead people to rest in peace rather than have their information revealed on the Internet or in Databases.





04 March 2023

HOW TO DEAL WITH SURNAME MYSTERIES #1 PRO GENEALOGY TIPS FROM ANCESTRY WORSHIP GENEALOGY BLOGSPOT

HOW TO DEAL WITH SURNAME MYSTERIES  #1  PRO GENEALOGY TIPS FROM ANCESTRY WORSHIP GENEALOGY BLOGSPOT

Have you ever been blocked in your research because you just can't seem to find the person by the SURNAME you have for them in databases?

Transcription and Indexing projects can be helpful but when the original handwriting is bad or the pages are faded or water damaged or the indexer did not have a clue about the ethnic surnames of the heritage/country/language they are working with, it's frustrating. The indexer was well meaning but it can mean hours of confusion for you. There you are, trying to figure out if that letter is an l or if the giant G you see is actually a J, or a T is an F. Frustration that might not be so acute if you were spinning microfilm. 

I say this because I've tried to recreate years of personal research on some of the most popular databases and I can tell you that NO, I would NOT find what I did using microfilm coming up on these databases.  (And in one case the clue I needed wasn't even on a microfilm but on the BACK OF A PAPER INDEX CARD! - which no one noticed when they were microfilming.)

That is why we always want to go to the original source material and see for ourselves what the index or database has taken us to. (And why I fear the destruction of source material.)

An indexer had the chance to properly translate a surname.

You have the chance.

You can use the Internet to your advantage.

I'm sure you've had the experience here on Google of searching for a topic but forgetting how to spell the word or words. The suggestion Google's intelligent search engine came up with makes all the difference because it spelled it correctly for you.  IT OFTEN CAN DO THE SAME WITH A SURNAME.

(I'm also sure at least some of you have had the hideous experience of automatic word corrections doing serious damage to your message - your text.  (I know my defunct cell phone did that and I started to hate texting because of all the wasted time fixing the words to what I had originally intended; sometimes the message still somehow went out wrong.)

This post is NOT to tell you that you should sit there and loose hours of your life, feeling ready to tear your hair out, trying to figure out what an indexer did not, though trying those T's that are J's and C's that are G's does sometimes make all the difference.

So here is my first tip...

USE AN ON-LINE LANGUAGE TRANSLATOR first to see if the name as you have is spelled HAS A MEANING. The translators are not always all-encompassing with their libraries of words and meanings, but this is a first step. You may be surprised at some of the meanings. Perhaps your ancestor went through life being known as Mrs. Dumpling.  Or Mr. Bellybutton.

At the same time, consider that some names, such as Baker, have variations that are close to each other in various languages.

If the surname has a suffix and the translator is not bringing up a meaning, but simply restating it as a word, try that surname without the suffix.

Be sensitive to the suffix as a particular language's way of adding words that mean - of, son, daughter, or some other possessive. This may be your clue to the ethnicity and language of the person and a way of confirming that you're looking at the right documents.  Sure, in some parts of the world there was ethnic mixing going on centuries ago and you may find Italians in Hungary or Scots in Poland. The incoming ethnic people may have slightly changed their name to fit into their new culture.

AN EXAMPLE:

In Polish a ski ending infers masculinity or the father, the patriarch side of the family.  Ska ending infers femininity and the mother, the matriarch side of the family. However, the name may though time move into the ski ending.  Ski indicates eastern slav origins and Sky indicates western sav origins.  

Szke is a Hungarian suffix meaning the same. In in some families both were used or you will notice the suffix evolving.

Ski, sky, vich, iew, ow, dotter, all indicate that somewhere along the line, a person took the original root name and added a possessive.  Which means that you may just find the link between the surnames in a sensible way, because you find the name without that suffix.

The name with an ow suffix may mean  "The man from Krak"  i.e. Krakow.

You'll notice that some possessives indicate a relationship with a person and others a relationship with a PLACE.

When it comes to places and times where people did not have to have a surname because everyone knew who was who in their village or the subculture they lived in within the village, there are two ethnic groups I can think of off hand here in which surnames were recent and did not stabilize for some time, and there was no need for legal name changes.

More on that in the next post!

This post is one of a series on the subject.  Click on the tag Surname Help - AWG to get to all the posts.

C 2022-2025 Ancestry Worship Genealogy BlogSpot

All Rights Reserved including Internet and International Rights

image from Graphics Fairy


15 December 2022

TILL WE MEET AGAIN IN THE NEW YEAR

Friends, I'm taking a little blogging break for the Holidays but promise you I will be back in the New Year.

This past year the big news was the release of the 1950 census. I'm still tangling with it a bit and love that it held some surprises.  What discoveries will we make in the coming months?  What mysteries will we solve?

In the New Year there will be a number of excellent books I'll be telling you about and recommending you read too. It's my hope that we will all maintain our sense of adventure about our research.

If you have any books or other materials that you would like me to know about, please use the Comments Feature to leave me a message.  I read all comments before publication and if you do NOT want me to publish your message to me, just say so and I will respect that.

I'm also open to some questions.  If you are blocked in some way, please leave as detailed a comment as you can explaining where you are in your research.

I'm always seeking resources that are new or that I don't know about. I'm sure that even as the big genealogy database companies load more and more on there is plenty more that one must find using older, pre-Internet methods.  I meet people who do not know that you can call an archive or even a library local to your ancestor's location to see what they may hold in special collections. If you are determined you seek it all.

Wishing you some Relaxation and Rejuvenation!

Christine




03 October 2022

DEDUCTIVE REASONING in GENEALOGY - NARROWING DOWN THE AGE OF DEATH TO FIND THE RECORD

Now that I've had my big breakthrough in my Polish line research, I've easily gone back a few generations but records I focused upon and would like very much remain missing or undiscovered. They are yet to be indexed for sure.  I've not found that the death records have much to offer in identifying who the dead person was married to. The death records seem to be the least indexed as well.

TO FOCUS and potentially reduce the time spent on looking for records page by page here is what I do.

I look at the marriages of the children.  If there have been two - three - four - marriages, I look at the marriages of the children from those marriages too because in these records there is a notation about each partner's heritage.  If possible start with the first married child and work forward in time.  If it says the parent is p.d. (parent deceased) you'll know that at the date of that wedding, that parent is dead.  Or both are.

ie. Jan's marriage  1835 parents both alive

     Marianna's marriage 1838 note that her father is diseased

      Sophia's marriage 1843 note that both parents are deceased.  

Therefore I know that I need to look from 1838 to 1835 for the death of these children's father.  And from 1843 to 1838 for the death of these children's mother.



12 May 2022

HIRING A GENEALOGY PROFESSIONAL? SOME ADVICE!

ANCESTRY WORSHIP - Genealogy BlogSpot contains a lot of 'how to' advice for those who are researching their own genealogy.  However, not everyone who is interested in their own genealogy has the time or the skills set to do it.  Or perhaps you started but had to stop and need someone else to continue the work. Or perhaps you just want a pro to help you get through a block. So if you are going to be working with a professional, here is some advice.

1) Gather up all the documents you can first, to present to the pro... Birth and death certificates, school diplomas, obituaries, bibles,  whatever you have.  While there may be more you find when the project has already begun, it is far more efficient and less expensive if you are organized and have these things to hand over or copy for the pro, who is going to be making some judgement on how to proceed.  Also, any research that has already been done, charts, and so on, hand them over.  These will be evaluated.

2) Also write out or plan a meeting in order to record or otherwise communicate any stories of the family history.  We know that these stories can be important - or may eventually be dismissed in favor of research - and will be discussed again. You may remember or collect more but do try to have them ready to present at the beginning of the project.

It may be useful to tell a story about great-grandma fighting to get an 8th grade education, however, we need to be specific as to which great grandma that was, her name, and other details, to record the story properly and place it where it belongs.

3) Expect that there may be times when the genealogist will request that you send in forms or provide your signature. There are certain records that are going to require your participation to obtain, others that a letter from a genealogist will obtain without.

There is no way around this.  If a genealogist asks you to fill out, sign, or send in a form, do so without delay.  You can't put it all in the hands of the pro because of the policies determined by governmental agencies that, for instance, only a child of a person in the military can obtain the information. That you know the date of someone's death is not the same as having a copy of a death certificate. 

(Currently I have a project held up for months. The client said she already had a certain vital record but had not found it or presented it to me, and we needed a certified copy for her International purposes. I thought the delay was Covid closure related, but after six weeks wait, it turned out she had not followed my instructions.)

4) Fees to governmental agencies and archives are your responsibility and also require your participation in the project. It's a good thing.  A genealogist does not profit from these fees, such as charging you $35 when the fee is $25, and you'll have a sense of where things stand on your project.  (However, a genealogist's charging to write a letter or filling out forms that require your signature is valid.)

5) If you have done some of the work, expect that the genealogist will need to review it and get their bearings on the project. Also, don't expect the genealogist to remember every date and every detail, especially if you are starting and stopping the project. What a pro will do is keep research copies to refer to. If more than a few months has gone by since you requested work last, expect another review process to start back up.

The pro will want to obtain copies of all documents possible in order to proof. There can sometimes be wait times of weeks or months when newly ordered or requested from archives. While the pro will use databases and some results come quickly compared to the old days, no database has it all and there are still times when other resources will have to be used. Census records are important and easy, but there may be other records that are only available to an immediate family member.

6) Communicate about how it is best to communicate with you. Are there certain hours or days in which you want to talk on the phone?  Do you prefer e-mail?  While there may be times when a quick message will be best, you may need to do in person meetings as well.

What hours does the genealogist work?   (I had one client who acted as if he was the only person I worked for, as if he owned me, who started calling inappropriately late, on Sunday mornings, and so on. as if pestering would make it all happen faster.  Needless to say, I ended working with him.)

At the same time, if you are too hard to get, that may be frustrating for the genealogist who is excited about the assignment and wants to buzz along.

If the genealogist is working out of a certain archive or library (though not necessarily an employee of it) realize that they may be there working for another client and you still need to respect an agreed upon meeting time. Do not interrupt them with questions and break their concentration before or after your meeting time.

7) Discuss privacy.  For instance, I never post my work for a client on internet or databases. 

That said, someone else that is related to you might put their work up there - without proofing it - which is, in my opinion, one of the worst aspects of the whole 'sharing' aspect of databases.  There is so much unreliable data that may even look official. One database I looked at had eight people doing charts relying on information about one person that had never been proven and I knew they had to be all following each other along. 

Original work is most often the best because you are paying for a pro's time and I know I find the time looking at other people's work can be time consuming.  Do I ever? Yes, but judiciously and usually only if the usual methods seem to not be bringing up useful data but then I'm going to question it. If something is posted that is not proofed - say that certain people were born in a certain place in Germany, I'm going to want to find those documents in Germany but only after the link to them has been proofed first.

Get a general idea of the pros and cons of exposing information for potentially millions of people to see and use but understand what may or may not be under the genealogist's control or your own control. 

8) Be realistic. This one is difficult to define. I love shows about genealogy of celebrities and watch them, sometimes learning from them, however, what you see on these shows appears almost miraculously. Sometimes several or many researchers who are experts in niche areas spent hundreds of hours working behind the scenes obtaining what you see in twenty minutes on the show. Also, I have the instinct that there may be situations in which, if the genealogy research is not going well for a certain person or proves to be not so interesting, that show might not proceed.  Putting together these shows is expensive and they want the stories that will hook you.

Also, the genealogist is not to blame if they themselves run into what is called "the brick wall" or "block" in which they must accept that the trail of ancestors can go no further or must "go around another way" which can be tricky, inconclusive, and expensive.  I've done this for my own family research, for instance, because records kept in church books only went back to the early 1800's, following other family with that surname to see if there was a connection just to add one more generation to a chart.  If I did that for a client I'd have to bill out an easy thousand.

9) There is no such thing as a "rush job" in genealogy.  There may be bits of information that can be obtained quickly, but in general, you have to go with the flow, as well as your agreement on how much time and money you want to spend.

Do not blame the genealogist if the finding is that no, that information does not exist.

Here is an example:  I found the Irish ancestors on the boat coming to America for one side of a client's family in less than an hour, but when I went to the other side, I found twelve candidates, all with the same names. This is further confused because on the ship manifest they reported the port as their last address and this was likely true because they first left a village and then worked for some time around the port to pay for the ticket...

The client had no identifying information at all, so I knew I would have to do much more traditional research that would take time. For instance, I would have wanted to find the family on census, pull from the Catholic archives of Boston, and also looked to see if perhaps any of the children had left clues on their documents. Anything that would give names of the parents, county of origin, would be helpful, though the request was to find so and so on the boat. Of course this would be more expensive and if the database wasn't pulling it up fast (and cheaply) then his interpretation was that this was my fault.

10) Be prepared for questions and surprises. Sometimes information comes up that refutes memory or oral history and that has to be brought up.

I've come up against this a few times, and frankly most often when it was a question of a missing or questionable birth parent.

So, I may not officially be able to be the spokesperson for every pro genealogist here, but it's my experience that a genealogist has seen and heard it all. Maybe more than your hairdresser or bartender.  Stolen children, murders, lies about who the birth parent is, confusion over ethnicity... speak up about your concerns!

In trying to find a way to the truth, we often speculate to ourselves or with our client.

In one sensitive situation, the client implored me "just the facts" but speculation can be helpful as we try to situate ourselves in that missing ancestor's shoes, their era, their ethnic culture, their family. 

Remember that a genealogist is not a therapist, so if you're having a problem processing that is being discovered, consider that the genealogist can't change what has happened in the past.

All for now!

C 2022 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy

15 January 2022

AN ANCESTRY FAMILY TREE BASED ON RUMOR THROUGH A RELATIVE'S RESEARCH WAY OFF

A distant relative that I made contact with a couple years ago told me the family story which I soon learned was full of rumor, gossip, and error.  She also said she didn't give a hoot about genealogy.

Sometimes stories can be proofed or can lead us to the correct information.  However, in this case I really wondered who might have had an agenda to defame someone.

After I explained that genealogy is not the same as family stories, though the two can unite, I told her one of her stories was just plain wrong.

Then I offered to find some documents for her.

I went into the Ancestry TM genealogy database where I almost never look at the family tree function.  I forgot to uncheck it and upon putting her mother's married name in, up came a family tree.  She had not put it up there, but who had?   I printed it out.  None of it had an attached document.  No death certificates.  No marriage certificates.  

I decided to use the locations stated on this family tree posting to search census for the surname - nothing.  Most bizarre was that her very own mother was reported to have been buried in Canada.  I know where her mother is buried and it's not Canada.  It turns out that someone had decided that a person with the same surname but her mothers given and middle name reversed was her mother.  What a mess.  

That mess should not be called genealogy.

I realized that someone might have basically put all this information up with best wishes or hope someone else would straighten it all out.

This is just one more example of errors which are all over databases and all over the internet that other people rely on as fact.

Even if you are a hobbyist, hold yourself to professional standards.  DO NOT ADD TO THE MISINFORMATION BY POSTING what is NOT DOCUMENTED on any database for other people to see or use or rely upon!  And do not believe any "genealogy" that does not share proof documents.

We already have enough rumor, gossip, and error.

C 2021  Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot

24 December 2021

HAPPY HOLIDAYS and SEE YOU IN THE NEW YEAR!

The end of the calendar year is a time to celebrate or  time to pause and think about the past and what we want for our future as individuals and collectively.  I want to thank all the people who have been checking into this blog to see what's up. Perhaps one of your New Year's Resolutions is to start back up with your personal projects.  Perhaps you worked on your projects during Covid-19 shut downs or unemployment and have put the project aside. Whatever the case, there is probably no end to the possibility that your research will lead you into new directions or more documentation.  I sincerely hope ANCESTRY WORSHIP - GENEALOGY BLOGSPOT has helped you in that endeavor.

Christine

ANCESTRY  WORSHIP - GENEALOGY BLOGSPOT


04 September 2021

RECLAIM THE RECORDS - I LOVE IT!

RECLAIM THE RECORDS 

EXCERPT:  We're RECLAIM THE RECORDS, a new not-for-profit activist group of genealogists, historians, researches and open government advocates.  We identify important genealogical record sets that ought to be in the PUBLIC DOMAIN but which are being wrongly restricted by government archive, libraries, and agencies. We file FREEDOM OF INFORATION and OPEN DATA request to get that public data released back to the public. And if the government doesn't comply, we take them to court.

I love this - I'm fine with it - so long as the privacy rights of individuals is respected.

29 May 2021

I REVIEWED THE WORK OF A PRO SALT LAKE GENEALOGIST AND WAS ANGERED

It's not uncommon for the work of one genealogist to be handed over to another. Recently a report, granted compiled in 2003, was handed over to me. It was compiled by a "certified" genealogist from a company that was lodged in Salt Lake City. (I will not comment on if it is still there.) The presentation of the research was rather professional for 2003, a booklet like the kind you can get from a photocopy company with plastic claw binding, nice logo and official looking. The report kept noting "sessions" as in "previous research sessions." Never the less, any information previously handed over to the client and repeated in this one should have shown documentation.

The client had paid for more information on their Irish Catholic ancestor who had come to the US about 20 years prior to the Famine and with an expertise. The report went forward with documents of his children BUT THAT WAS NOT THE PROBLEM. The problem was a family mystery. He had gone to Hawaii and disappeared. There was no further communication from him other than a letter from him stating that he had made it, or so the story went. I asked to see the letter and read it aloud to the client. It was clear that there had been an estrangement as he says he has not heard from anyone in a long time as if he's been cut off, he suggests he will return if that's what's best wanted. In a long PS he suggests maybe his wife and family might want to move to Hawaii.

The date of the letter cannot suggest when he left or even how long it took to be recieved. 

My research showed that it could take six months or more each way to get a letter from New York to San Francisco. A year or more could have gone by.

Of course I cannot know how many times this pro communicated with the client and what was said but I started to feel angry that so much time had been wasted. 

There were photocopies of books read seeking some mention of mystery man's, name and in the business he was supposed to partake in. Since he was not supposed to be an owner, I saw this as a debatable pursuit.

Had he died? When? Did he forget his wife and children and marry another women? Had he gone and failed, perhaps because Protestant missionaries were busy in Hawaii and he was Catholic and was not allowed into the ship captain, missionary, sugar business cabal? Maybe he died of disease or fell off another boat. Or he had to find the work of a common laborer  - with Chinese - and had not a cent to get back home. Then there was the mail which could take months - had he sent another letter that was never recieved? Had she replied?

When had he died and where?

I'm reminded of a person I knew years before who was illegitimate. Her mother told her to tell people her daddy had been killed in the war circa 1948. I wondered if the whole Hawaii thing had been a deal circa 1848 between a couple who couldn't divorce!

This report I was reviewing was a culmination of various "sessions" over many pre database years. It was clear to me this genealogist was hinting at more books he could read but had failed to find the mystery man on records. This can happen despite extreme efforts. But where was evidence that a proper search had been made?

And if someone wanted to disappear mid 1800s it was a lot easier than today. The long sail trips around the Cape Horn - the spirit of adventure - he could've written a letter and had a shipmate friend mail it from Hawaii. 

But one fact hit me. The widowed wife of an immigrant was able to send a son to college and law school. How was that afforded? How did a woman with children who never remarried in the pre Civil War days in a town in a smallish North Eastern town keep going? Had one or both of them come to America from Ireland with a fortune?

Further she bought land in her own name about 1846. This any feminist genealogist will tell you is a clue. A couple years before the date on the letter. Did she come with money of her own?

And one had to have land there and then in New York to become a citizen.

Immediately I suspected she knew her husband was gone for good though the letter that supposedly stated he had "made it" to Hawaii was 1848. I reread the letter.

Was it possible that her husband never came back to her but did prosper to send money for years? Had there been a quiet divorce? The potential for court records and land purchase had been unexplored.

The report repeated the family story, perhaps a mythology. There is no documentation for the story.

There is no name of a ship. No departure date. No manifest. No citizenship. No church records.

The thing that most struck me is that if it was not at the Latter Day Saint's Family History library in Salt Lake, it was as if that resource did not exist. 

Therefore, after an hour of research with five pages of my notes in hand, I asked the client to give me all previous research sessions.

A much fatter report from 2002 began with evidence of trying the Hawaii State Archives and University of Hawaii to report on their collections and some of these collections held potential but there was no evidence that any of them had actually been examined by anyone, stating he'd have to go to Hawaii to look. No - that's when you're supposed to actually contact an archivist there for guidance or pay them! Same thing about Irish archives.

Irish genealogy can be problematic due to a repetition of common names. I've had to tell a client there were 16 men with the same name coming over the same year - there was more that could be done - but he didn't want me to look for naturalization that would give me the town because he didn't want to pay more.

Years into this professional's research there was a note of a naturalization in New York but no copy of it. Perhaps it would state where he was born in Ireland. Yet in 2003 the pro was still ? On the place and date of birth.

I was researching at and through LDS Family History Centers at least as far back to 2000. Why had he not looked at/ for the naturalization? Indexes are meant to help us get to originals.

There is no evidence of a search for wills. Or confirmation of the land purchase of land.

I started to feel angry. 

Imagine when I got to the middle of a pile of reports and noticed a different genealogist working for the same company had started this same research problem in the 1980s and had actually done, despite more obstacles, more and better research. Still, no documentation.

*****

Believing undocumented family stories is a genealogy myopia.

*****

It's ethical for a pro genealogist to say they gave hit into a brick wall and can go no further with what's available. 

It's another to not look at appropriate available records just because they are not at an LDS or other research library.

*****

My recommendations are for the descendant who inherited these reports to go forward with Hawaii State Archives, the Catholic diocese of Honolulu, and the Catholic diocese in the US, as well as land purchase and naturalization for the woman who reportedly never knew what happened to her husband. If court records are not in existence, II would still approach historical societies and reach out to libraries local to the questions 

It's good to know history and read books about Hawaii developing but not realistic to find mention of a worker who was not an owner or executive in these authored and edited books. However, details about the island. Catholic Missions, and Sugar might enrich the story, such as telling what the island was like when the ancestor wrote his letter.

I would learn more about how someone might get to Hawaii from the East Coast. Based on Catholic and Irish heritage it's my notion the port of Boston would've been used.

C 2021

28 March 2020

EVIDENCE OF INHERITANCE ON CENSUS

Did one person in the family outclass the others?

There is sometimes evidence of this on the census.

Some things to consider:

If you have an adult sibling group, did the oldest son perhaps inherit from the Old Country where only the oldest son was a recognized heir? If so he may be living in a house while the others rent or be able to afford rent beyond his obvious income. What is his profession?

Is he perhaps a factory worker living next to a doctor or a bond salesman? If you can't really determine how much the real estate they live in was worth on the market that year or in that place and use a inflation calculator the kinds of work neighbors do can be telling!

You may want to research the general inheritance laws and/or practices in the ethnic country of origin. What went on in Germany did not always go on in Hungary, but Germans in Hungary might continue to practice the same rules of inheritance, as an example.

Is he living in an ethnic ghetto or near other family members.  Possibly the person who has more or earns more is the first to leave the ghetto for the suburbs.

Did a daughter "marry up?" In days past - and that includes the 1950 census - when most women became wives, housewives, and mothers, and were totally dependent on a husbands income, this may be evident in the profession of her husband as compared to that of her siblings.  Sometimes it is because a daughter had a father with an inheritance to provide a formal or informal dowry that she was able to marry up.  Another possibility is that college was afforded for the daughter and there she met a man who was educated or a professional as a husband.

You may  be able to find titles to land or actual wills and other legal documents that would show inheritance beyond a census.

C 2020 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot

25 December 2019

BEST WISHES

May all of  you who are in pursuit of genealogy and family history have wonderful holidays and an enlightening New Year - 2020.

27 July 2019

SEARCH FOR HERITAGE - ORPHANAGE - ADOPTION - LOVING HOME - Research Path Heritage Search 1 - One


I offered to help an adopted person who, in the 1990's, went through two years of living hell to get his original birth certificate. He has memories of being in a Catholic orphanage. It wasn't all bad but then he got out of there before the age of five. He was there for about a year and a half. He was not abused. He got parents who were devout Catholics and is to this day himself devout.  They were good and loving people.


After he located his birth mother, who was still alive, he contacted her and went to visit her. She recognized him instantly and also told him that she had prayed every night of her life for a reunion. From then on she was included in his family, got to know her grandchildren, and even the parents who adopted him accepted her as a member of their family.

He never contacted his birth father. 

His birth mother had herself been in a Catholic orphanage in another state. Her emancipation from the orphanage was like what happens today with many foster children who age out of the system; 18 and nowhere to go.  Today these 18-year-old emancipated foster children find themselves struggling to support themselves in an increasingly expensive world. It's not uncommon for them to become homeless. After turning 18 and being let go by the orphanage she had been in, this gentleman's mother took the train to another city where another of the orphans, who had left a couple years earlier, offered to take her in.  

World War II was brewing.

Having the real names of both his birth parents, I encountered a glowing obituary for his father. Perhaps the man who deserted his mother wasn't all bad, but I had to wonder if the woman he did marry and the many children he had with her ever heard they had a half-brother out there somewhere. 

One of those children apparently pridefully did a big family history on FAMILYSEARCH.  I could easily email him through their system but would not do that behind this man's back.  I promised him that I would not post anything on databases or Internet about our search for more information about his family's origins, especially not identifying information. Nor will I contact them. This is the confidentiality that I can personally promise. I can't guarantee that no one else is working on the same question or family.

I'm going to post on how I'm approaching this. Maybe some of you will want to follow along. To link to the posts on this particular research path, click on the label below that says Research Path Heritage Search 1.

It's his birth mother's side I'm working on and since the orphanage she was in was the intake for Catholic children in a certain mid-west city and the surname is prevalent there, it's first a matter of looking at all the families with that name on census and seeing where she would fit or not in birth order. And also doing that for him. 

His birth mother said that her mother died giving birth to her and there were several older brothers. That her father had visited her every weekend until he died. Then her brothers shunned her. So of course, I want to find a birth certificate for her mother that fits the story.

But ah... One sometimes uncovers lies when doing genealogy and family history research.

Let's all say a little prayer for this situation, this person.  Unlike some persons who were adopted, he is not striving to become part of a family that did not want his birth mother.  Simply he and his wife want to travel to the towns in Europe that his immigrant ancestors left and enjoy that heritage. At least that's the start of it.

C 2019 Ancestry Worship Genealogy Blogspot
To follow along on this genealogy research path click on the label below that says Research Path Heritage Search 1

Note: This post was slightly edited for clarity on August 14, 2019





23 September 2018

THE MISSING PERSON - GENEALOGY versus THE DETECTIVE

I recently met someone who is related to a MISSING PERSON.  The missing person went on a vacation to see relatives and rented a car, deciding to go to another city that is a tourist trap before returning home.  Who hasn't used an extra day or so when near some attractions to go see them, a once in a lifetime opportunity, when far from home? Months ago he was last heard from by cell phone.  All seemed to be well. He was a loving father and family man. They didn't actually think of him as missing until about a week later when he didn't use his return ticket. Until then a lot of rationalizing was going on. The cell phone was never found but went dead.  Later the rental car was found with no evidence of him in it. The family feels they did all they could do including making appeals for information on television, posting on Facebook, and so on.  Now they have faith in God and see him in their dreams.  

MISSING PERSONS! The mystery of what happened to them and when, not knowing if and when they were a victim of criminals or an accident, or if they went missing deliberately for some unknown reason, challenge loving family in every way possible. I personally feel this person is not on this earth, but it is too soon too soon to give up hope.

I find that the work of David Paulides
CANADIAN AMERICAN MISSING - DAVID PAULIDES is quite fascinating.  

Paulides is broadcasting via interviews and YouTube almost weekly, focusing on some of the most mysterious disappearances in National Parks, in a very open minded way that might include BigFoot or UFO's, which I realize turns some people off.  Yet, he remains on the side of true detective work and skepticism and is probably the person most responsible in North American for working on the problem of ineptitude in investigations, unaccountably of and bureaucratic messes in governmental agencies when it comes to missing persons. 

Listen to him and you'll begin to wonder how so very many people could be simply gone.

He says that one should never go hiking without a partner, am electronic device that would help locate you (not just a cell phone), and a weapon. 

So, is there a way to use genealogy instead of a detective to work on this missing person case?

The answer is NO. The situation is too new. Possibly if the situation is old enough, there might be some evidence that the person just went away and settled somewhere else. 

I consider birth parents gone missing to be traceable using some genealogy methods. I was able to locate one father within hours of being asked to. He had not changed his name.

A person may not actually be "missing" if they did not go out of their way to change their identity, such as changing their name. Because of electronic databases and informational services, to go missing on purpose is more difficult by the minute. But once in a while you hear of someone who just went away, found employment, someone who never divorced but remarried.  Their neighbors are astounded to find out that they were actually a WANTED PERSON all those years when they'd been considered to be pillars of their community.

Police detectives have access to databases that may help track a person's movements and expenditures. Making missing persons reports with police is a first step.  It's often not enough.  A person who wants to disappear is probably not going to use their credit cards or the same phone. They are probably going to leave with a lot of cash on hand and have made plans to go from here to there - such as another country - in advance. It's not impossible but generally difficult to have that much cash in hand if you're an ordinary individual. Off to another country we might consider how well did they speak Spanish or Polish when they left?  Yet, I reason, everyone has a secret life, a self they keep private. It's possible that the missing person had some associations his wife and children knew nothing about.

Sometimes it's just that an agency budgets only so much time and money to a case. Then it goes COLD.

If there is a person who is missing that you want to find, try to avoid certain assumptions such as that they are missing because their Facebook page is static or taken down. Maybe they're just taking a time out from social networking.  Additionally, maybe they are taking a break from YOU.  Maybe the relationship was not as good as you imagined it. (Are you a stalker with an imaginary romance?)  

One person asked me, "What if they went into a Witness Protection Program?"  Well, I don't know exactly how that works.  From reading around it, the person being protected has to check in frequently with law enforcement.  To start a new life elsewhere the FBI may have helped with name changes and ID's and so on. And the person or family has to be ready to be moved again - and again.  I doubt that an individual with a loving family would go and leave them behind without telling them but in the Witness Protection Program, it can be no-contact. Usually people in this program are in it because they are considered to be on hit lists or in deep trouble because of their testimonies against criminals.  Witness Protection Program people live very controlled lives. 

So, Blessings to those who are missing someone they love, as they cope with the changes in their lives because of the mystery of what happened.

C 2018  Ancestry Worship Genealogy BlogSpot

Update July 2019.
The missing man's remains were found, in a field not far from where the rental car had been found.  Foul play is suspected.

02 February 2018

DEFENDING GENEALOGY

There are many reason's why people do genealogy research, for themselves and for others.  Like many people who are self taught professionals, personal research was the start for me, back in the day before Internet and databases, and I still use the old resources.  Came the day when I was up against a "brick wall," on my personal research.  I had to wait a while for the information I needed to reach me.  And while I was waiting I started working on a friend's genealogy because I just needed to keep learning.

Not all projects I do turn into books.  Sometimes I work only on a specific question.

Recently I found myself having to defend my love of genealogy and the time I put into it (which is not excessive.)  Oh, I knew this person was ignorant but I also sensed she was  afraid.  I was put down.  Things said to me included, "I think anyone who has to go to the library three days in a row is weird."  "Who cares about the past? I live in the present."  and "You know how you write letters? Well, write nothing about us."

I'll start with that last one.

My experience as a professional and with other professionals is that they respect privacy more than your average person.  They sometimes sign confidentiality agreements (usually when working for someone famous).  There is a lot of information out there for free or for cheap these days and an average person can find out a whole lot about someone else without their permission.  There are criminals who use that information.  Let's just say that I am as careful as I can be to keep a project within the confines of the family I'm working for and with.  However, I've had the experience of the family then doing what they want with that information, usually making copies for their relatives.  I do have to write letters to a client's relations at times.  They know it's a professional asking for information and they know who has hired me and so on, so it up to them to not respond.  (That has happened, even when it was important, and I don't pester.)

As for "living in the past," I think it is quite possible to be curious about ancestors and how they lived and to do some research around their times and place, society and culture, without actually living in their past.  Since we do not yet have a time machine to transport those now living into the past, of course it is impossible.  Then there are people who are such aficionados of an era that they do everything possible to live in it to escape the present as much as possible.  There are fans of the 1930's and fans of the 1950's who own cars, decorate houses, and wear the clothes of their era. They might shun the Internet and cell phones!  I love DNA science and anthropology and archaeology and, as my readers know, I'm also fascinated with past life regression and that the soul chooses to incarnate repeatedly.

As for myself, those who know me know I am also very interested and concerned about the future, in particular the ecosphere of our planet, beginning with my own neighborhood.

As for weird, you might find this weird but I could easily research far more than three days a week, and sometimes I have.  On one project I did three twelve hour days because there was a legal deadline involved.  I am never bored by this research.  I am enlivened by it.  Often there is something of helping people involved in it.

So let me get to the FEAR, since this person is a relative by marriage.

I have been pondering why a particular person may not want to know of ancestors or relations who are not in their immediate presence or memory. Perhaps in some way such a person is overwhelmed with the ones she knows and can't imagine having to include even more people into her worries or around the holiday table.  Because of her attitude I am no longer showing her any of the documents I found.  I know at least one of her grandchildren are interested and the day will come when it is proper to present this grandchild with her genealogy.  I personally have thought of some of my ancestors as incredibly strong people because I learned about the things they had lived through and because I discovered the role of religion and faith in their fortitude!   ... Just about every family has some secret or scandal or someone they don't like for whatever reason...

C 2018  Ancestry Worship BlogSpot  All Rights Reserved