Showing posts with label Crime and Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Crime and Justice. Show all posts

30 April 2025

THE BRYAN KOHBERGER TRIAL NEARS and I'M JUST AS INTERESTED IN THE INVESTIGATIVE GENETIC GENEALOGY DNA EVIDENCE ASPECT OF THE CASE

September 5 2025: Just a note here... As you may know Kohberger decided to admit his guilt and there is no trial. He has his sentence and is in prison for life. 

THE BRYAN KOHBERGER TRIAL NEARS and I'M JUST AS INTERESTED IN THE INVESTIGATIVE GENETIC GENEALOGY DNA EVIDENCE ASPECT OF THE CASE


It's been a while since I posted about my interest in the "Idaho Four" Murder case.  Although I'm not a follower of True Crime podcasts in general, I have spent many hours listening to various podcasts about this one. Some of the podcasters and the people they interview make me crazy because, overall, the man has been convicted and is assume to be guilty even when they make a mention of that fact that in the United States we presume innocence, while going on to talk about him specifically as the murderer. Listening to a variety of opinions is good because it certainly opens one's mind to possibility. For instance, I do think there is reason to consider that there was more than one murderer involved in the killing of the four students, two weapons, two styles of stabbing or gouging, and a timeline that would mean to me that a person would probably have to be a killing professional to kill four persons so quickly.  Day by day, as more information that was kept away from the citizen and the media, is released, some notions are challenged, while others make more sense.

It's been a couple years now since Koberger, once a PhD. candidate student studying criminology, was arrested.  His lawyers are thorough and a third has recently been put on a case in which many thousands of documents must be looked over by attentive staff. This case includes much that is modern such as videos, door bell cameras, cell phone pings, and the DNA  which is "Touch DNA." Using Genealogy database as well as going through his family's garbage cans, the FBI matched his father with "Touch DNA" on the metal button of a leather knife protector left at the scene.  The knife itself has not been found. The database and the relative did not give permission. But what's in place to stop law enforcement?

As a genealogist, the use of Genealogy databases and DNA testing service databases is of the most interest to me. It's clear that everywhere we go and everything we do, we are leaving trace evidence of our existence. I was thinking about this the other day because I'm the only person on earth besides her owner, a friend of mine, who can hold a small Jack Russel terrier named Princess. Princess is extremely protective of my friend and/or is terrified of just about every other human or dog that lives. Princess has been shedding all over me, all over.  I see that and I think about shedding a few skin cells wherever I go.

I think we are all challenged with a conflict here of wanting a murderer caught but also wanting our personal privacy. In a recent court pretrial ruling it was determined that this DNA evidence would not be used...

KREM : KOHBERGER PRETRIAL DETERMINATION DNA

Excerpt: Both sides agreed not to introduce evidence obtained through Investigative Genetic Genealogy (IGG). Instead, the state will rely on a "tip" that led to Khoberger. The court also reserved ruling on a motion involving evidence of alternative perpetrators, requiring the defense to submit offers of proof by a set deadline.

On the topic of DNA evidence, the court granted a motion to exclude misleading population comparisons related to likelihood ratios presented to the grand jury. However, it would not restrict similar questioning during the trial. A defense motion to exclude testimony about an "inconclusive" DNA likelihood ratio was denied as moot, as the state said it would not use it as inculpatory evidence.

Here is an explanation of TOUCH DNA https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-46051-9

Touch DNA: impact of handling time on touch deposit and evaluation of different recovery techniques: An experimental study
C 2025 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot

18 January 2023

A DISCUSSION ABOUT DNA PRIVACY (THERE ARE MANY WAYS TO BE FAMILY)


The arrest of the man alleged to have murdered the four Idaho college students is said to have been achieved through, among other things, DNA testing. I would love to know which DNA testing databases sold for GENEALOGY purposes were used to identify his DNA at the crime scene. Although we like the fact that DNA can free someone who is not guilty but sentenced and imprisoned, or because of arrest and imprisonment, not commit a crime again, this is a discussion we need to have.

I'm often asked if I have done DNA genealogy for myself and family.  The answer is no.  I'm satisfied with what genealogy research tells me at this point.  

Thinking about the reveals that various people have told me (not a huge poll, I realize) when they hear I'm a genealogist, I would say about half have had some mind-challenging result, from discovering one was adopted and not actually blood-line wise, Native American, to that grandma had an affair and the family genetically belongs to a different Scottish clan.

Let's pause a moment and think about WHAT CREATES A FAMILY.  And for some of us it's about CHOICE.  There are many people who have not or will not marry and have children, and these people in the past were often not included on genealogy charts because - well - they had not reproduced.

Also for me, I knew that my family was ethnically mixed while still in Europe and if you find that your family came from the noble or aristocratic class back in the day the chances are greater that your ancestors traveled far for marriages.  

We must also look at the fact that countries and borders that are in place now, were not always.  People identified themselves as belonging to an ethic group or a locality group and there were disputes.  An area that is mostly Germany but with a high population of French.  An area that is now in Romania where most people are Hungarian.  An area that was once Hungary is now Slovakia.  A small portion of Poland that was Hungary.  And so on.  

I realize that when you're hooked on genealogy, you really don't want to quit and DNA may have some answers for you...  I understand, totally, for I too have hit the end of the road on many of my lines.  But in the end, it probably does not matter.

Perhaps one of the reasons I feel this way is that, although I don't know how it works, I am partial to the recycling of souls called "reincarnation."  Perhaps we have the experience of many cultures over time.  I'm also interested in "genetic memory" and the idea that we retain something of our parents and grandparents life experience.

These are my thoughts as we head into 2023...

If this is your first stop to ANCESTRY WORSHIP, welcome!

C 2023 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot