Showing posts with label Family Mythologies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Family Mythologies. Show all posts
09 May 2021
28 October 2019
ROBERT THE BRUCE OR GERONIMO : GENEALOGY FAMILY MYTHOLOGIES
In the past I've stated that I don't believe we are responsible for what family in the past did or didn't do, good or bad, that we are our own person and responsible as adults here and now for ourselves and our behaviors. And one of the stereotypes of people interested in genealogy is that they're snobs, seeking only to brag about the accomplishments of their ancestors, particularly if these ancestors are still famous for their deeds. That's not me. If I found nobility in my family it would prove one thing; that if you have nobility in your family you can usually go further back into your research. Though some of the people in the current generation have noteworthy accomplishments to their credit, no one I know of is famous.
I admit to wondering who of my ancestors, if anyone, I'm like as a personalty and character, and in particular if I look like anyone, since I feel I do not. I'm also from a family that seems to have no photographs of ancestors and I doubt I will ever see any. Years ago my snail mail letters to people in old age who I had reason to believe were related were not responded to. I even heard certain members of my family thought my interest in genealogy and family history was "weird."
This brings me to the fact that I have met MANY people who claim to have ROBERT THE BRUCE or GERONIMO as an ancestor. One person claimed she'd actually traced her family back to Robert.
Much is known historically about both men.
Robert the Bruce, King of Scotland, left one surviving son named David II when he died in 1329.
Geronimo, Bedonkohe "Apache" leader of the Chiricahua had many wives - at least five - and died in 1909. Living descendants seem to know who was who if you think you may be related it would seem there are websites where these people have posted that you might be able to join on.
The last person who told me he was related to the Robert the Bruce was a beginning amateur genealogist who I caught in a number of questionable statements and was probably repeating a family rumor.
The last person who told me she was related to Geronimo had the name of a wife.
I don't want to discourage anyone from loving and learning to research and proof your ancestry, including the oral histories that people have repeated to you. It is usually time consuming and requires fortitude and patience. You have to evaluate other people's work if you link on to it and it is all too easy to believe whatever you see posted.
C 2019 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot
I admit to wondering who of my ancestors, if anyone, I'm like as a personalty and character, and in particular if I look like anyone, since I feel I do not. I'm also from a family that seems to have no photographs of ancestors and I doubt I will ever see any. Years ago my snail mail letters to people in old age who I had reason to believe were related were not responded to. I even heard certain members of my family thought my interest in genealogy and family history was "weird."
This brings me to the fact that I have met MANY people who claim to have ROBERT THE BRUCE or GERONIMO as an ancestor. One person claimed she'd actually traced her family back to Robert.
Much is known historically about both men.
Robert the Bruce, King of Scotland, left one surviving son named David II when he died in 1329.
Geronimo, Bedonkohe "Apache" leader of the Chiricahua had many wives - at least five - and died in 1909. Living descendants seem to know who was who if you think you may be related it would seem there are websites where these people have posted that you might be able to join on.
The last person who told me he was related to the Robert the Bruce was a beginning amateur genealogist who I caught in a number of questionable statements and was probably repeating a family rumor.
The last person who told me she was related to Geronimo had the name of a wife.
I don't want to discourage anyone from loving and learning to research and proof your ancestry, including the oral histories that people have repeated to you. It is usually time consuming and requires fortitude and patience. You have to evaluate other people's work if you link on to it and it is all too easy to believe whatever you see posted.
C 2019 Ancestry Worship - Genealogy BlogSpot
13 June 2015
NO LINK BETWEEN VLAD TEPES AND ELIZABETH BATHORY - LET'S LOOK AT THIS FROM A GENEALOGICAL AND REINCARNATIONAL POV
A nice lady named Elizabeth contacted me a while back hoping that I could be quoted, if there was some link, through genealogy or reincarnation, between two notorious figures of Old Central Europe, Vlad Tepes (otherwise known as Vlad the Impaler) who lived in Transylvania and was Romanian and a Prince and military leader, and Elizabeth Bathory, a Hungarian countess who was probably mentally ill, and who may have murdered dozens of beautiful young girls, in order to preserve her own youth or beauty.
It seems that the Hollywood horror flick mythologies of Hungarians and Romanians as creepy people is taken for history and with all the media fascination, films and television shows that are occult based, about witches and vampires in recent years, I suppose there are a lot of people who feel familiar with and enjoy "the dark side" and want to explore "power."
The story of Elizabeth Bathory is associated with evil, with vampirism, and of power over the powerless, like a huge number of Slovak servant girls gone missing. Were they so desperate for work that when their friends disappeared but they still went on interviews to the manor house?
No one should be worried about Elizabeth and inheriting mental illness, which I believe to be schizophrenia, unless they can trace their genealogy and DNA back to her through their MATERNAL LINE. Science has now proven that while sons inherit the gene for this mental illness, they cannot pass it on through their children. It is passed from a mother to her children, meaning only Elizabeth's two daughters could pass it on. Even then there is evidence that a person can have the gene for it and not develop it and further that about 20% of schizophrenics are spontaneously healed of the mental illness as they age.
It seems unbelievable to me that the locals didn't know something was amiss and put a stop to it before so very many young women were disappeared. Remember that there were so fewer people alive on earth back in those days, fewer people per square mile, fewer people to keep track of, less anonymity. People lived off the land, agriculturally, and even if there was a manor house or castle or estate with a town around it everyone knew everyone because the main business of the estate was agricultural so in the villages they were seeing people they knew frequently, working with them every day, and gossiping about each other, keeping track of who married, who had babies, and who died.
What is implied is that because Elizabeth Bathory was noble and came from a powerful family she could get away with anything, that no one, not even her husband or family, would put a stop to her behavior, and that they were all sociopaths if they didn't try to stop her because all this was simply not right.
I found this site that is interesting http://bathory.org/shyla.html Anyone wishing to quote the owner of that site would need to get in contact with them. And you would want them to provide their documentation for each statement.
If we look at this story from a genealogical POV, trying to prove it, we would need documentation recorded in reliable old books and ledgers. I've yet to find any documentation of any murders that Elizabeth might have committed through anything close to a public or civil record, but according to this site, she recorded 612 deaths in her diary. So let's go back to the reality of living in those days, the smaller population, the way everyone knew everyone, and consider that 612 girls lured to torture and death, is greatly over and beyond the numbers that some of our most notorious mass murderers have been able to get away with today. Think about 612 girls in a relatively short period of time and in one place. What did she do with the bodies? Maybe her diary is full of her hallucinations and ravings?
Since such subjects are of fascination, I've met people who say that they think Elizabeth, a powerful lady, was the subject of slanderous accusations.
So many things about Elizabeth Bathory's life were ordinary. She was from nobility and she married a noble. She married, she had children, she was supposedly able to compartmentalize so well that she was considered a loving mother. Who hasn't heard another woman being called a bitch or witch today? .
Was she "a witch"? As for "witches," people should know that during the times these people lived in, the accusation of witchcraft could be used on any woman who was not understood, or any woman who had not married or had children, or who was considered ugly or deformed, or who was different, or simply not liked. People were born into their class, their roles in this life and there wasn't a lot of tolerance for people who were different. It was an era of superstition, not science. When people accused other people of being witches, they were not talking the present day organization called Wicca, or nature worship, or the paganism of say, Native Americans. Talk of evil and witches (and Satan) was almost always that of people who were Christians and Bible based.
As for reincarnation, this is where I'm really thrown. Is there someone claiming to be a reincarnation of either or both Vlad and Elizabeth out there? Certainly I've never met anyone claiming so or heard of anyone claiming so.
And let's wrap our minds around this further, Vlad may have chopped off the heads of those he killed in battle and put them on spikes, but he wasn't the only one. This tactic was used by the Turks. It was used in South East Asia in the 1960's and 1970's. The same tactic of exhibiting the heads of those killed is being used by ISIS. Terrifying.
Reincarnation has been accepted as a spiritual reality by Hindus, Buddhists, and many other religions throughout the world for a long time. It was a matter of belief. A sensibility. These days, through the use of hypnotic regression, and through the testimonials of children who recall past lives, there seems to be more evidence for it. Having a past life or lives and recalling it through these means, dreams, deja vu, and so on, is not associated with "the dark side," or evil.
That's not to say that people never remember horrible things happening to them while regressed.
I was in a classroom in which everyone was regressed and there was a couple there who believed themselves to be soul mates who, in the past life they shared, were both victims of a concentration camp during the WWII Holocaust.
It seems that the Hollywood horror flick mythologies of Hungarians and Romanians as creepy people is taken for history and with all the media fascination, films and television shows that are occult based, about witches and vampires in recent years, I suppose there are a lot of people who feel familiar with and enjoy "the dark side" and want to explore "power."
The story of Elizabeth Bathory is associated with evil, with vampirism, and of power over the powerless, like a huge number of Slovak servant girls gone missing. Were they so desperate for work that when their friends disappeared but they still went on interviews to the manor house?
No one should be worried about Elizabeth and inheriting mental illness, which I believe to be schizophrenia, unless they can trace their genealogy and DNA back to her through their MATERNAL LINE. Science has now proven that while sons inherit the gene for this mental illness, they cannot pass it on through their children. It is passed from a mother to her children, meaning only Elizabeth's two daughters could pass it on. Even then there is evidence that a person can have the gene for it and not develop it and further that about 20% of schizophrenics are spontaneously healed of the mental illness as they age.
It seems unbelievable to me that the locals didn't know something was amiss and put a stop to it before so very many young women were disappeared. Remember that there were so fewer people alive on earth back in those days, fewer people per square mile, fewer people to keep track of, less anonymity. People lived off the land, agriculturally, and even if there was a manor house or castle or estate with a town around it everyone knew everyone because the main business of the estate was agricultural so in the villages they were seeing people they knew frequently, working with them every day, and gossiping about each other, keeping track of who married, who had babies, and who died.
What is implied is that because Elizabeth Bathory was noble and came from a powerful family she could get away with anything, that no one, not even her husband or family, would put a stop to her behavior, and that they were all sociopaths if they didn't try to stop her because all this was simply not right.
I found this site that is interesting http://bathory.org/shyla.html Anyone wishing to quote the owner of that site would need to get in contact with them. And you would want them to provide their documentation for each statement.
If we look at this story from a genealogical POV, trying to prove it, we would need documentation recorded in reliable old books and ledgers. I've yet to find any documentation of any murders that Elizabeth might have committed through anything close to a public or civil record, but according to this site, she recorded 612 deaths in her diary. So let's go back to the reality of living in those days, the smaller population, the way everyone knew everyone, and consider that 612 girls lured to torture and death, is greatly over and beyond the numbers that some of our most notorious mass murderers have been able to get away with today. Think about 612 girls in a relatively short period of time and in one place. What did she do with the bodies? Maybe her diary is full of her hallucinations and ravings?
Since such subjects are of fascination, I've met people who say that they think Elizabeth, a powerful lady, was the subject of slanderous accusations.
So many things about Elizabeth Bathory's life were ordinary. She was from nobility and she married a noble. She married, she had children, she was supposedly able to compartmentalize so well that she was considered a loving mother. Who hasn't heard another woman being called a bitch or witch today? .
Was she "a witch"? As for "witches," people should know that during the times these people lived in, the accusation of witchcraft could be used on any woman who was not understood, or any woman who had not married or had children, or who was considered ugly or deformed, or who was different, or simply not liked. People were born into their class, their roles in this life and there wasn't a lot of tolerance for people who were different. It was an era of superstition, not science. When people accused other people of being witches, they were not talking the present day organization called Wicca, or nature worship, or the paganism of say, Native Americans. Talk of evil and witches (and Satan) was almost always that of people who were Christians and Bible based.
As for reincarnation, this is where I'm really thrown. Is there someone claiming to be a reincarnation of either or both Vlad and Elizabeth out there? Certainly I've never met anyone claiming so or heard of anyone claiming so.
And let's wrap our minds around this further, Vlad may have chopped off the heads of those he killed in battle and put them on spikes, but he wasn't the only one. This tactic was used by the Turks. It was used in South East Asia in the 1960's and 1970's. The same tactic of exhibiting the heads of those killed is being used by ISIS. Terrifying.
Reincarnation has been accepted as a spiritual reality by Hindus, Buddhists, and many other religions throughout the world for a long time. It was a matter of belief. A sensibility. These days, through the use of hypnotic regression, and through the testimonials of children who recall past lives, there seems to be more evidence for it. Having a past life or lives and recalling it through these means, dreams, deja vu, and so on, is not associated with "the dark side," or evil.
That's not to say that people never remember horrible things happening to them while regressed.
I was in a classroom in which everyone was regressed and there was a couple there who believed themselves to be soul mates who, in the past life they shared, were both victims of a concentration camp during the WWII Holocaust.
12 January 2015
AN OLD POST ON ANCESTRY BOARDS BRINGS UP A STRANGE STORY
The other night I was trolling through some old posts I put up on Ancestry years ago, not knowing that they were actually going to be on the INTERNET (I thought only on the innards of the then small genealogy database) and which, frankly, I deeply regret posting. I lost the password in to delete these myself and have to write to Ancestry to have them all taken down.
NOT ONE POST IN ALL THOSE YEARS EVER RESULTED IN ANY GOOD INFORMATION SHARING, just a lot of new researchers speculating and hoping that the social networking aspect of the site would bring them other people's research for no effort on their part, sad to say. Which is why I think there are a lot of people willing to give subscription databases a spin, without being willing to put the time and effort in, and terribly ignorant that you still often have to use the OLD FASHIONED methods like books, microfiche, films, and writing away to governmental archives.
But strange - someone did post about a year or so ago on one of these many posts I made and it was a story about someone whose surname was similar to the person I posted about. This poster said that the person I posted about was said to have brought with them (on a steamship) enough GOLD to last THREE GENERATIONS.
I had to laugh.
My research on this line is now EXTENSIVE and HARD WON, as well as EXPENSIVE, but I have never found ANY evidence that there was even enough GOLD to live well in the first, immigrant, generation. There isn't one person in the entire family who hasn't worked until they were sick or dead.
THAT MEANS IF THERE WAS GOLD it was buried or lost.
The tale might even have some PIRATES in it!
NOT ONE POST IN ALL THOSE YEARS EVER RESULTED IN ANY GOOD INFORMATION SHARING, just a lot of new researchers speculating and hoping that the social networking aspect of the site would bring them other people's research for no effort on their part, sad to say. Which is why I think there are a lot of people willing to give subscription databases a spin, without being willing to put the time and effort in, and terribly ignorant that you still often have to use the OLD FASHIONED methods like books, microfiche, films, and writing away to governmental archives.
But strange - someone did post about a year or so ago on one of these many posts I made and it was a story about someone whose surname was similar to the person I posted about. This poster said that the person I posted about was said to have brought with them (on a steamship) enough GOLD to last THREE GENERATIONS.
I had to laugh.
My research on this line is now EXTENSIVE and HARD WON, as well as EXPENSIVE, but I have never found ANY evidence that there was even enough GOLD to live well in the first, immigrant, generation. There isn't one person in the entire family who hasn't worked until they were sick or dead.
THAT MEANS IF THERE WAS GOLD it was buried or lost.
The tale might even have some PIRATES in it!
27 December 2011
DOCUMENTING LONG FRIENDSHIPS : LET'S NOT FORGET THE NEVER MARRIED AND THE CHILDLESS AMONG US!
There is such an emphasis on official family - bloodlines - in genealogy that I would like to talk to you all about documenting other, important, non-official, friendship, as a part of a family history project.
Friendship is also an important part of our lives and special friends, those who have known us for years, should be part of our oral history, written history, and inclusion. When someone has lived with or partnered with another person and has considered this to be a marriage, a marriage which was not or cannot be legal, we cannot pretend this relationship did not or does not exist.
There is so much emphasis on family in genealogy and family during these holidays. Let us not forget those who never married or never had children!
Friendship is also an important part of our lives and special friends, those who have known us for years, should be part of our oral history, written history, and inclusion. When someone has lived with or partnered with another person and has considered this to be a marriage, a marriage which was not or cannot be legal, we cannot pretend this relationship did not or does not exist.
There is so much emphasis on family in genealogy and family during these holidays. Let us not forget those who never married or never had children!
18 April 2011
TRICKY! SITUATION IN GENEALOGY : MYTH MAKING RELATIVES
One project I'm working on requires that I go against a myth that a woman created long ago to hide the fact that she was married after she became pregnant. Today this is common statistically (as is unwed motherhood) in the United States. But even today among more conservative or religious people it is a rarity. Even today many Westerners believe that they should wait until they are married to have sex (and since most Americans STILL marry in their early twenties this may not be so difficult!) Many more believe that contraception is a responsibility until the couple can afford a child or children. So for many such behavior is a shame. This woman who has spent a life hiding her before marriage pregnancy was born in the 1920's and was pregnant in the 1940's. My research will blast apart a mountain of lies. But that is not my intention. My intention is to prove the facts with documents. Not only was the 50th anniversary of this couple (You would think that 50 years together might absolve some sins!) celebrated by her family on a day that has nothing to do with the real date and well past the birth date of her daughter (excuse - a surprise party) but the invitations were carefully worded and designed not to mention any dates at all. Genealogy research must be proven (fact checked) and such lies cannot stand in published research.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
